Nolan made two changes to the side that drew with Luton Town on the final day of the regular season. Ben Hall and Michael O’Connor returned to the bench, with stand-in skipper Richard Duffy and midfield maestro Liam Noble coming in.
A pre-match deluge left the surface soggy and the game started in scrappy style with Shaun Brisley being called into early defensive action, blocking Jack Grimmer’s goalbound effort. Notts’ response came from Jorge Grant, who sent an effort over the bar on the half-volley moments before the Magpies suffered a double scare. Marc McNulty’s low cross-shot struck the far post and Brisley had to be on hand once more to deny Max Biamou on the follow-up. Notts’ first big chance came on 17 minutes when Forte met Grant’s corner at the near post but could only send the ball over with a header. That sparked a good spell of pressure for the visitors, who saw Dan Jones fire a yard wide before Forte forced Lee Burge into an incredible save when he managed to turn Jones’ free-kick goalwards. The keeper somehow hooked the ball out for a corner with his feet. Coventry replied with a near miss of their own, McNulty scampering to the byline and almost squeezing the ball past Collin at the near post. Stead struck into the side-netting and McNulty blazed high and wide as the clock ticked down towards half-time. But there was still time for the hosts to spurn an excellent chance to take a lead into the break, Bayliss being played into the area but rolling his shot wide of the far post. Determined to end the half on a high, Notts pressed through Grant in injury time. The Forest loanee nutmegged an opponent to set himself up for a shot but could only send the ball over, leaving the match goalless at the break.
There were no changes and Notts nearly had the dream start to the second half when Elliott Hewitt sent Burge’s punch looping back over the keeper with a header. A Coventry defender did well to clear the ball off the line. Coventry countered and nearly took the lead themselves when Grimmer headed over from close range. But it was to be the Magpies who would draw first blood – and in sensational style. Jones slid in to win an emphatic challenge down the left before picking out Forte with a low cross. The forward adjusted his feet superbly to flick the ball past Burge in front of Notts’ jubilant supporters. A wave of Notts pressure followed and Forte came agonisingly close to a second when he tried to scramble the ball home on the goal line, only for Burge to hang on for dear life. Burge was then equal to a Grant effort which skipped up off the slippery surface as Nolan’s men continued their pursuit of a precious second goal. Sent on to aid their efforts was Lewis Alessandra, replacing Matty Virtue down the right. But, buoyed by a 17,000-strong crowd, Coventry upped their search for an equaliser when Bayliss fired narrowly wide and McNulty went close with a deflected header. Sent on to steady the ship was Michael O’Connor, replacing Noble and taking the captain’s armband from Duffy. But there was nothing the skipper could do to prevent the hosts from being awarded a highly contentious penalty when Tootle was adjudged (incorrectly, according to television replays) to have felled Bayliss in the box. McNulty made no mistake with the spotkick, levelling the tie with only three minutes of normal time to play. The tension and frustration was palpable and O’Connor joined team-mates Grant (74’) and Duffy (86’) in the book for a rash challenge shortly before six minutes of added time were indicated. A couple of nervy moments followed as the hosts nudged two efforts narrowly wide before Forte hobbled off to be replaced by Alan Smith. But 1-1 was how it stayed, setting up a tantalising second leg at Meadow Lane next Friday.
Coventry City: Burge, Grimmer, Davies, Hyam, Stokes, Bayliss, Kelly, Doyle, Shipley (Ponticelli 72), Biamou (Clarke-Harris 83), McNulty.
Booked: Hyam, Stokes, Doyle.
Notts County: Collin, Tootle, Duffy, Brisley, Jones, Virtue (Alessandra 58), Hewitt, Noble (O’Connor 77), Grant, Forte (Smith 96), Stead.
Booked: Duffy, Grant, O’Connor.